Jump to content


Photo

RootsMagic V6 - very first impressions

New features

  • Please log in to reply
1 reply to this topic

#1 GeoffB

GeoffB

    Member

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 23 posts

Posted 20 November 2012 - 12:03 PM

Being a long time user of RootsMagic ever since version 3, I cast care aside and went headlong for the upgrade from RM5 to the recently heralded version 6. This is offered to such as me at only 65% or so of the full cost to new purchasers – suggesting significant improvements.
I cannot claim that I have had sufficient time to rigorously ‘track-test’ v6.

However, my first impressions lead me to question whether RootsMagic is becoming a little like those has-been rock bands which habitually seem to release new albums at the run up to Christmas that turn out to be essentially rehashed collections of earlier tracks with – if you’re lucky – one or two previously unreleased additions (that probably were not considered good enough earlier).

Not to be too cynical, the new program does offer some welcome new features:
  • the ‘live time view’ is a significant addition and the ability to edit from this screen will undoubtedly prove useful
  • the ‘find everything’ facility helpfully addresses concerns that I and others have expressed about previous shortcomings in how searches could be conducted and, in particular, allows text associated, for example, with media items to be included
  • I’ve yet to be able to do justice to the new ‘web-tags’ feature but this looks to be useful – up to a point. However, unless I’ve missed it, there doesn’t appear to be a way of including such links within reports/web pages etc – hopefully I’m wrong!
  • The county check facility seems to have been expanded and improved. I cannot judge if this is now useful to those of you across the pond but, as one who lives in England, I place little or no trust in its authenticity (the United Kingdom does not date from 1066, only 1707!). That said, you can switch it off and the program is only as good as the sources of information it uses
  • On-line publishing via the new free RootsMagic service is clearly a welcome extra feature. I have not yet tried it and would be pleased to know a little more about how it will operate – eg is it secure?, is the data shared? etc. Whilst it is good for those who want to use it and have not already availed themselves of other competitor services, it does seem to me to be (to use current parlance) more a facility that should be an ‘in-app purchase’ – ie an extra which can be bought by those who need it rather than it being funded by a higher upgrade price for those who don’t. Perhaps that’s getting too picky!
  • As to the dozens of other enhancements, perhaps these will become evident in time….
Credit where its due, RM continues to be a great program and it is good that the developers to appear to listen and – I assume – look at what their competitors are doing.

I do, though, lament the fact that v6 is still apparently offers not facility to include more than one small media item in its narrative reports (along with the ability to edit size, orientation, captions etc). This is a long standing request that I and others have pressed for and is a glaring omission.
Similarly, the almost total lack of any ‘hotlinking’ within reports and charts (eg so that you can click to jump to the next relevant page in a pedigree chart or to the parents/children in a narrative chart necessitates substantial post-editing when compiling published data.

Also still no ‘all-in-one’ trees to allow the generation of reports that go wider than the direct ancestral line or the inclusion of a limited number of ancestors of (say) spouses/partners in a descendant tree. It would, for example, be useful to be able to chart all those specified within a Group (assuming they are related) to be shown on a chart or report.

Hey Ho – there is always next Christmas….

#2 Vyger

Vyger

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 3258 posts

Posted 20 November 2012 - 05:05 PM

I cannot judge if this is now useful to those of you across the pond but, as one who lives in England, I place little or no trust in its authenticity (the United Kingdom does not date from 1066, only 1707!)


It didn't.

I do, though, lament the fact that v6 is still apparently offers not facility to include more than one small media item in its narrative reports (along with the ability to edit size, orientation, captions etc). This is a long standing request that I and others have pressed for and is a glaring omission.
Similarly, the almost total lack of any ‘hotlinking’ within reports and charts (eg so that you can click to jump to the next relevant page in a pedigree chart or to the parents/children in a narrative chart necessitates substantial post-editing when compiling published data.

Also still no ‘all-in-one’ trees to allow the generation of reports that go wider than the direct ancestral line or the inclusion of a limited number of ancestors of (say) spouses/partners in a descendant tree. It would, for example, be useful to be able to chart all those specified within a Group (assuming they are related) to be shown on a chart or report.


Have you posted specific wishes for these enhanements either on the forum or via RM support ?

“Your most unhappy customers are your greatest source of learning.” -Bill Gates

 

 

User of Family Historian 6.2.7, Rootsmagic 7.5.8, Family Tree Maker 2014 & Legacy 7.5 (in order of preference)

 

Excel to Gedcom conversion - simple getting started tutorials here

 

Root






Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: New features